The complex case of fintech regulation in Pakistan

Fintech covers digital innovations and technology-enabled business model innovations in the financial sector. Such innovations can disrupt existing industry structures and blur industry boundaries, facilitate strategic design- termediation, revolutionize how existing firms create and deliver products and services, provide new gateways for entrepreneurship, democratize access to financial services, but also create significant privacy, regulatory and law- enforcement challenges. Examples of innovations that are central to Fintech today include crypto currencies and the block chain, new digital advisory and trading systems, artificial intelligence and machine learning, peer-to-peer lending, equity crowd funding and mobile payment systems.
(Thomas Philippon, NYU)

Fintech is reshaping the financial industry and its rapid rise is prompting the financial regulators to come up with new regulations. This has been a headache for some regulators as Fintech poses new challenges every day. Some countries are embracing it while some are still struggling to understand the benefits of having a growing Fintech ecosystem. No business can thrive without the support of the regulators, especially a financial business.

The complexity

Overall global financial landscape changed with the clamp down on terrorist financing and money laundering. These issues are pertinent to Pakistan as well.

In fact, Pakistan has been one of the most severely hit countries in the world. We are fighting terrorism and according to State Bank’s own admission, a large amount of money is being taken out of country each day for laundering purposes. These are two of the factors that regulators have in mind when they bring in tight regulations.

A number of countries have started to pay attention to the potential of Fintech. These countries are trying to create an environment where Fintech start-ups can grow without compromising the security of the customers.

Pakistan’s missing link

Data theft is one of the biggest fears; regulators have to make sure that the aspect of security remains paramount. However, putting these safeguards in place ought not to deter new entrants. In fact, some of the measures will become counter-productive if implemented without involving the industry participants. Most of the start-ups are the creation of individual minds. These people may not be familiar with the regulations or understand the implications of having them in place.

Singapore and India have understood this and both these countries have dedicated teams for Fintech start-ups. Their regulators have created windows for the Fintech start-ups that focus on these issues. This creates an environment for the start-ups to collaborate with the regulator.

This is also the key reason that Fintech start-ups have been flourishing in both these countries. In Singapore, their regulator, Monetary Authority of Singapore, has detailed pages on how to set up a FinTech business in the country. In contrast, we cannot find anything in Pakistan from the regulators. Pakistani regulators are treating Fintech Start-ups as the banking institutions and same regulations are being applied.

Hong Kong has gone even further as there are some peer-to-peer lending platforms active in the country. WeLend was already working while AliBaba and Tencent launched their own digital banks, MYbank and WeBank, in the mainland China. We know that informal lending is quite common in Pakistan. However, if someone was to establish a similar business in Pakistan, they will have to acquire a banking license, which is super expensive. While peer-to-peer lending platforms are not engaged in lending, they provide a platform to willing lenders and borrowers. While this looks like an extremely attractive business model, setting it up in Pakistan will be an uphill task despite the benefits it will bring.

Regulatory developments and SBP’s Role

In 2014, SBP released Rules for Payment System Operators (PSOs) and Payment Service Providers (PSPs). The PSOs and PSPs may include the following:

1. Electronic Payment Gateway Service Providers to perform routing and switching of payment transactions/messages to facilitate:
a. E-Commerce
b. Remittances
c. Point of Sale (POS) network

2. Clearing Houses to provide payment related clearing services.

3. ATM Switch Operators to provide routing of ATM transactions through inter-connectivity between the participants of the network.

4. Any other Payment System Operator or Payment Service Provider as may be permitted by SBP.

State Bank of Pakistan also fixed the minimum paid-up capital requirement for the PSOs and PSPs at Rs200 million or any other amount as may be prescribed by the bank from time to time; for each PSO or PSP-related business application an additional 25% capital may be required.

This amount looks quite daunting on its own and acts as a major barrier of entry for the start-ups, however it does not stop here. They will be required to maintain (at all times) at least 10 percent of the required capital or any other amount prescribed by the bank as security deposit at SBP Banking Service Corporation (BSC) Office. Five percent of the security deposit will be kept in a non-remunerative current account with the SBP-BSC Office and five percent in the form of government security to be kept under lien at the SBP-BSC Office.

PSPs usually do not require a banking license in other parts of the world because these operators use the system of their partner banks. Setting up these requirements for the PSPs creates another hurdle for these businesses in Pakistan.

The way Forward

While there can be no compromise on security and money laundering; it also needs to be said that State Bank can certainly do a lot more to facilitate these start-ups. These businesses can help stimulate considerable economic activity. Countries like Singapore, China, Hong Kong, Australia and India have realized what Fintech can bring to the table. For Pakistan to develop a successful regulatory environment, State Bank needs to be more active and consider the following:

1) Define the goals and rank preference in terms of; fostering stability , access to services and promoting entry of new firms
2) Engage Industry for adaptation to Regulation
3) Develop an awareness campaign or an online page like Singapore MAS
4) Develop Consumer protection laws- to create the trust factor through robo- advising

Thomas Philippon in his research paper for NYU further emphasized the importance and role of regulatory bodies and that may be a great advice for a nascent structure like Pakistan’s;

Regulations are likely to be more effective if they are put in place early, when the industry is young. A counter-factual history of the money market mutual fund industry can be used to motivate this idea. Suppose that regulators had decided in the 1970s that, as a matter of principle, all mutual funds should use a floating NAV. Such regulation would have been relatively straightforward to implement when the industry was small, and it would have guided its evolution and encouraged innovations consistent with the basic principle. It is significantly more difficult today when the industry has several trillion of dollars under management. A challenge for regulators is then to be forward-looking when dealing with FinTech. Effective regulation requires them to identify some basic features they would like FinTech to have in thirty years, and mandate them now.

About the Contributor:

Ishtiaq Ahmed is an equity research and financial analyst. He has been studying the North American, European, and emerging markets. A regular writer for and Motleyfool, two of the most read equity research platforms in North America. His areas of interest are Oil & gas, Utilities, Technology and Telecom.

News of the day

7 minutes Read 237 views

Pakistan’s first online hostels booking platform is now...

July 29, 2019

The prevalent problem among students and working professionals today is that people living out of their hometown and…

View All
6 minutes Read 241 views

Summer Camp for Teens! CAMP AMAZE!

May 27, 2019

Innovation District 92 is hosting Camp Amaze, a Summer Camp for students aged 14-18 years in…

View All
11 minutes Read 286 views

ATX+PAK Advance GMAP Finalists Announced

May 6, 2019

Ten startup companies to launch accelerated global expansion plans via Austin, Texas

The City of Austin Texas, Innovation District…

View All
6 minutes Read 305 views

Last Day To Apply For A Fully Funded...

April 24, 2019

Today is the last day to apply for the University of Oklahoma Professional Fellows Program for business owners,…

View All
8 minutes Read 452 views

OpenMic, a Nest I/O startup, has launched to...

December 11, 2018

OpenMic, a social startup that engages youth in the conversations about the future of Pakistan, conducted its…

View All

Latest Videos

1 minute Read 1,000 views

Saad Mahmood, The Technology Guy

March 13, 2018

Saad Mahmood is currently working at Microsoft.He is Microsoft Most Valuable Professional (MVP) and loves technology. Saad has…

View All
1 minute Read 988 views

Saad Mahmood’s Perspective About Women Empowerment !!

March 8, 2018

Saad Mahmood is currently working at Microsoft.He is Microsoft Most Valuable Professional (MVP) and loves technology. Saad has…

View All
Less than a minute Read 1,802 views

CEO VizRah, Mohammad Adeel Javed, talking about Vizrah...

August 20, 2017

We asked Adeel Javed about his initiative VizRah and how he aims to positively impact the society through…

View All
Less than a minute Read 2,475 views

Yellow Plate Restaurant introducing fast food with unique...

August 10, 2017

Our team visited Yellow plate restaurant at Shah Jamal market Lahore to tantalize our taste buds. The Owner…

View All
Less than a minute Read 1,700 views

Views of Khuram Bukhari (Co-Founder Ravvish) about Life,...

August 10, 2017

We conducted a written dialogue about life and success with Co-Founder Ravvish, Khuram Bukhari

View All